Religion is a potent force for cooperation and conflict, research shows
May 17, 2012
Across history and cultures, religion increases trust within groups but also may increase conflict with other groups, according to an article in a special issue of Science.
“Moralizing gods, emerging over the last few millennia, have enabled large-scale cooperation and sociopolitical conquest even without war,” says University of Michigan anthropologist Scott Atran, lead author of the article with Jeremy Ginges of the New School for Social Research.
“Sacred values sustain intractable conflicts like those between the Israelis and the Palestinians that defy rational, business-like negotiation. But they also provide surprising opportunities for resolution.”
As evidence for their claim that religion increases trust within groups but may increase conflict with other groups, Atran and Ginges cite a number of studies among different populations. These include cross-cultural surveys and experiments in dozens of societies showing that people who participate most in collective religious rituals are more likely to cooperate with others, and that groups most intensely involved in conflict have the costliest and most physically demanding rituals to galvanize group solidarity in common defense and blind group members to exit strategies. Secular social contracts are more prone to defection, they argue. Their research also indicates that participation in collective religious ritual increases parochial altruism and, in relevant contexts, support for suicide attacks.
They also identify what they call the “backfire effect,” which dooms many efforts to broker peace. In many studies that Atran and Ginges carried out with colleagues in Palestine, Israel, Iran, India, Indonesia and Afghanistan, they found that offers of money or other material incentives to compromise sacred values increased anger and opposition to a deal.
“In a 2010 study, Iranians who regarded Iran’s right to a nuclear program as a sacred value more violently opposed sacrificing Iran’s nuclear program for conflict-resolution deals involving substantial economic aid, or relaxation of sanctions, than the same deals without aid or sanctions,” they write. “In a 2005 study in the West Bank and Gaza, Palestinian refugees who held their ‘right of return’ to former homes in Israel as a sacred value more violently opposed abandoning this right for a Palestinian state plus substantial economic aid than the same peace deal without aid.”
This dynamic is behind the paradoxical reality that the world finds itself in today: “Modern multiculturalism and global exposure to multifarious values is increasingly challenged by fundamentalist movements to revive primary group loyalties through greater ritual commitments to ideological purity.”
But Atran and Ginges also offer some insights that could help to solve conflicts fueled by religious conviction. Casting these conflicts as sacred initially blocks standard business-like negotiation tactics. But making strong symbolic gestures such as sincere apologies and demonstrations of respect for the other’s values generates surprising flexibility, even among militants and political leaders, and may enable subsequent material negotiations, they point out.
“In an age where religious and sacred causes are resurgent, there is urgent need for joint scientific effort to understand them,” they conclude. “In-depth ethnography, combined with cognitive and behavioral experiments among diverse societies (including those lacking a world religion), can help identify and isolate the moral imperatives for decisions on war or peace.”
Atran is also affiliated with Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique−Institut Jean Nicod, Paris, and with the John Jay College of Criminal Justice at the City University of New York.
Established in 1949, the University of Michigan Institute for Social Research (ISR) is the world’s largest academic social science survey and research organization, and a world leader in developing and applying social science methodology, and in educating researchers and students from around the world. ISR conducts some of the most widely-cited studies in the nation, including the Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan Surveys of Consumers, the American National Election Studies, the Monitoring the Future Study, the Panel Study of Income Dynamics, the Health and Retirement Study, the Columbia County Longitudinal Study and the National Survey of Black Americans. ISR researchers also collaborate with social scientists in more than 60 nations on the World Values Surveys and other projects, and the Institute has established formal ties with universities in Poland, China, and South Africa. ISR is also home to the Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR), the world’s largest digital social science data archive. Visit the ISR Web site at http://www.isr.umich.edu for more information.
Contact: Diane Swanbrow
swanbrow@umich.edu
734-647-9069
University of Michigan
Less educated Americans leaving religion behind
August 21, 2011
While religious service attendance has decreased for all white Americans since the early 1970s, the rate of decline has been more than twice as high for those without college degrees compared to those who graduated from college, according to new research to be presented at the 106th Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association. Read more
Holograms reveal brain’s inner workings
August 17, 2011
Like far away galaxies, powerful tools are required to bring the minute inner workings of neurons into focus. Borrowing a technique from materials science, a team of neurobiologists, psychiatrists, and advanced imaging specialists from Switzerland’s EPLF and CHUV report in The Journal of Neuroscience how Digital Holographic Microscopy (DHM) can now be used to observe neuronal activity in real-time and in three dimensions—with up to 50 times greater resolution than ever before. The application has immense potential for testing out new drugs to fight neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s. Read more
Doris Day releasing a new album after 20 years
August 16, 2011
Doris Day is making a musical comeback, releasing her first album in almost 20 years.
The 87-year-old screen legend, had her first hit record Sentimental Journey in 1945. She went on to become a Hollywood movie star in such film classics as Calamity Jane and The Man Who Knew Too Much and has won both an Oscar and a Grammy. Read more
Mike Myers Signs For ‘Austin Powers 4′ Sequel
August 13, 2011
HitFix reports that star and creator Mike Myers has signed on to a fourth film in the iconic role of Austin Powers, as the groovy, transported 60s-era British secret agent The last Austin Powers film was 2002′s critically maligned but massively successful, “Goldmember,” which co-starred Beyonce and made $296,000,000 at the box office. Meyers made three mega-hit Austin Powers spy spoof flicks in five years before calling it quits. But Meyers movie career has hit some bumps in the road and this will be his first trip back to the starring live-action big screen since his 2008 bomb. No word yet on who will be directing, but one has to imagine that the studio and Myers would be interested in bringing back Jay Roach, who directed all three previous films.
Warrant Singer Jani Lane Dead At 47
August 12, 2011
Jani Lane (born John Kennedy Oswald), the former lead singer of the of 1980s hair-metal band Warrant, has died in Los Angeles. He was 47.
Police report that Lane’s body was found Thursday in a Woodland Hills hotel, but no immediate information on the cause or circumstances of his death. Read more
U.S. set to call for al-Assad to step down as violence mounts in Syria
August 10, 2011
Source: Wikipedia. Author Fabio Rodrigues Pozzebom / ABr
The United States appears to be moving toward issuing an explicit call for Syrian President Bashar al-Assad to step down, U.S. government sources have leaked. The news comes after several Arab nations condemned the violence, also prompting the United Nations Security Council to meet again Wednesday, a week after issuing a strong statement condemning the government crackdown on opposition protesters and calling for the violence to stop. Read more
‘Explosive’ Jackie O Confession Tapes Reportedly Set to be Released (False Rumor)
August 8, 2011
It seems that Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis recorded secret confession tapes with the historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr., but asked that they not be released until 50 years after her death, fearing the confessions would have made her family targets for revenge. According to the London Daily Mail they’ve been vaulted since their recording a few months after her husband’s death, and although she died only 17 years ago, her daughter Caroline Kennedy has agreed to release them early and have them aired on a special program on ABC. It is believed she agreed to the release in exchange for the network dropping their $10 million series about the family.
Ted Bundy’s Newly Found DNA Could Help Solve Cold Cases
August 6, 2011
Ted Bundy Mug Shot - 1980
Notorious serial killer Ted Bundy, known for his charm and good looks, confessed to more than 30 murders before he was sent to Florida’s electric chair in 1989, but experts have always believed there were more. The true toll of Bundy’s killing sprees is likely never to be known precisely, but more than two decades after his execution in Florida, a vial of Ted Bundy’s blood has been found in Florida and investigators will use the newly discovered evidence to try to solve cases that went cold decades ago. Read more
‘Credible Lead’ In 40-Year-Old D.B. Cooper Airline Hijacking (Update)
August 1, 2011
One of America’s greatest unsolved crimes in which a hijacker parachuted out of a plane with $200000 ransom money has a credible new lead according to the FBI. Famed hijacker DB Cooper disappeared when he jumped out of a plane over Washington with $200,000 dollars in ransom the night before Thanksgiving, 1971. His fate remains unknown, although law enforcement have previously said they believe he died the night he jumped. Read more