Probes into Bloody Afghan Battles at Keating, Ganjgal Whitewash McChrystal’s Role

February 22, 2010

(ChattahBox)—Military inquiries into two of the bloodiest battles of the War in Afghanistan, have concluded that two lower level field commanders are to blame for a series of actions and decisions that contributed to the deadly October 3, 2009 ambush at COP Keating and the Sept. 8, 2009 assault in the Eastern Kunar province in Ganjgal. The probes found that the decision to keep a remote and undermanned outpost open in Barg-e-Matal, diverted resources, personnel and air support when needed for the battles at COP Keating, also known as the Battle of Kamdesh, and Ganjgal. But an investigation by McClatchy, found that the official inquiries overlooked Army Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal’s role in ordering that Barg-e-Matal be kept open for both strategic and political reasons, despite the fact that it was in a remote area and was vulnerable to constant attack.

Four American soldiers lost their lives from July through September in Barg-e-Matal, five U.S. soldiers were killed in Ganjgal when they were pinned down by an assault by militant insurgents, without air cover support, and the bloody battle of Kamdesh at COP Keating, sometimes referred to as the “Black Hawk Down” of the Afghanistan war, the worst single American combat loss in 2009, left eight American soldiers dead and 22 wounded.

Rear Adm. Gregory Smith, the spokesman for Army Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal, the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, told McClatchy news services that the threat from insurgents in Barg-e-Matal “was both significant and real.” “Everyone knew why we were in Barg-e-Matal,” one U.S. defense official said. “McChrystal . . . was not in favor of pulling out because of the political ramifications.”

Nevertheless, the official inquiries did not hold McChrystal accountable for his decision. Two lower level field officers; Col. Randy George and Lt. Col. Robert B. Brown were disciplined for their “ineffective actions” that led “directly” to the deaths of their fellow soldiers. But according to McClatchy’s report, the two officers had urged McChrystal for months to close Keating and Barg-e-Matal.

George was hit with a letter of admonishment and Brown was given an official reprimand. The reprimand is quite serious and could end Brown’s career.

“Two American defense officials and a former NATO official” told McClatchy that the two officers are scapegoats:

“They are screwing these two guys,” the first U.S. defense official said of the field commanders. “They were looking for heads,” the second American defense official said. “It’s a travesty.”

“This will make the Army even more casualty-averse,” said the defense official. “This is the worst message at the worst time for McChrystal to send.”

McClatchy reported that, “Army Lt. Gen. Guy Swan, who conducted the Keating investigation, didn’t return calls seeking comment on why his report, which found that manning Barg-e-Matal delayed Keating’s closure for several months, didn’t hold McChrystal or any other general officer responsible for that decision.”

Gen. McChrystal’s spokesman further defended the top commander’s decision in Barg-e-Matal:

“The decision on the scale and tempo of support to Barg-e Matal was balanced against other competing operations,” said Smith, who added that the local militia in Barg-e-Matal is “doing a pretty effective job, so the investment has paid dividends.”

Whatever the case, the unnamed “two American defense officials and a former NATO official” believe that McChrystal and other top generals escaped blame for an ill advised policy to keep the remote outpost open in Barg-e-Matal, which subsequently led to the deaths of American soldiers.

Source: See McClatchy for more.

Photo Source: by U.S. Army Sgt. Matthew C. Moeller, 5th Mobile Public Affairs
Detachment, Flickr photo stream.


3 Responses to “Probes into Bloody Afghan Battles at Keating, Ganjgal Whitewash McChrystal’s Role”

  1. Brian Johnson on June 22nd, 2010 8:09 am

    As the father of one of those fallen heroes, I would like hear further, about the “dividends” my son’s blood is paying. To the best of my knowledge, Gangjal is still standing in defiance of Afghan and US forces and except for letters of reprimand or admonishment no one has paid for the blood we’ve left in those mountains.
    While the end of an Army career may be a serious matter, I’m sure he’ll pop back up with a more lucrative job with a security contractor. My son and his brothers-in-arms aren’t so lucky.

  2. Deb Mace on October 11th, 2010 9:45 pm

    There are far more questions than answers about the decisions being made in Afghanistan… My husband’s son, Stephan Mace, was KIA at Cop Keating … and Gen Swan’s investigation is hardly satisfactory to family members… little information can be gleaned from the highly redacted report, except that the Army continues to cover up it’s actions rather than take full responsibility at the highest levels… and to learn from its errors… the battle at Wanat was laden with opportunities for learning … but rather, the Army chose to cover up … despite the findings of an independent investigation… and a year later, the battle at COP Keating occurred… and it is so eerily similar to Wanat that one cannot help but think that the Army has no real interest in being responsible for the actions of high commanders… or of preventing needless loss.

    I am glad Gen McChrystal sunk his own career by his unprofessional interview… he needed to be gone… and the Army was not going to do it… thank goodness for his own stupidity because in the end, it was the only way he was going to be out.

    As someone who grew up as a military brat, later a military wife… and now enduring the death of my husband’s son… I can honestly say the military of today is not one I recognize… and the leadership is not one I can respect… Blessings to our soldiers who are at the mercy of ineptitude.

  3. Susan Price on December 13th, 2010 10:28 pm

    As the Mother of Fallen Hero Gunnery Sgt Aaron M Kenefick, USMC, KIA Ganjgal, Afghanistan, Sept 8th, 2009, I too would like to hear about the behind the scenes matters regarding those negligent officers contributing to my Sons death and the other fallen heroe’s this day!!! So many unanswered questions, who these officers were, who they answered to, and who gave them the orders to stand down their posts….
    My Son and the other fallen heroe’s were left abandoned…These men gave their hearts and paid the price with their souls, one might imagine their last thoughts as my son and the others called over and over for air support….There is a God and he knows all….I will pray that justice will be served if it takes me a lifetime for my family and my fellow Gold Star Families to achieve some peace here on earth!!!!

Got something to say? **Please Note** - Comments may be edited for clarity or obscenity, and all comments are published at the discretion of - Comments are the opinions of the individuals leaving them, and not of or its partners. - Please do not spam or submit comments that use copyright materials, hearsay or are based on reports where the supposed fact or quote is not a matter of public knowledge are also not permitted.